How California’s Homeowners Insurance Market Fell Into Crisis—And What’s Being Done To Fix It

​For decades, homeowners insurance in California was predictable—a competitive marketplace, stable rates, and widespread availability. That’s no longer the case.

Today, homeowners across the state are facing skyrocketing premiums, policy non-renewals, and shrinking coverage options. Insurers are pulling back from high-risk areas, while others have stopped writing new policies entirely.

At the same time, California’s auto insurance market is also in crisis, with drivers experiencing similar issues—rising premiums, fewer carriers, and stricter underwriting. While these two crises share some common causes, including outdated regulations and rising claims costs, they also have distinct challenges.

For homeowners, the biggest issue isn’t accident lawsuits or repair costs—it’s the growing threat of wildfires and the financial risks insurers face when covering homes in high-risk areas.

Why California’s Homeowners Insurance Market Is Failing
While inflation and rising construction costs have made rebuilding more expensive, the root of the problem is that California’s insurance regulations haven’t kept pace with today’s wildfire risks.

For years, insurers absorbed massive losses from wildfires, counting on profits from other areas of the country to offset their California home insurance business. But as wildfires have become larger, more destructive, and more frequent, that strategy is no longer sustainable.

Rather than continue operating at a loss, many insurers are pulling back from high-risk wildfire zones, reducing coverage, or leaving California entirely.

Rising Rebuilding Costs and Demand Surge
Rebuilding after a wildfire is significantly more expensive than it used to be.

• Wildfire-damaged communities often face material shortages. High demand for lumber, roofing, and skilled labor after a major disaster drives up prices.
  
  
• Contractor availability is limited. With so many homes needing repairs at the same time, labor shortages cause delays and increase rebuilding costs.
  
  
• Extended replacement coverage can help, but it may not be enough. Many policies include extended replacement cost coverage, but if rebuilding costs soar beyond those limits, homeowners are left paying out of pocket.

With higher claims payouts than ever before, insurers have no choice but to raise premiums or exit the market.

The Growing Reliance on the California FAIR Plan
As traditional insurers pull back from wildfire-prone areas, more homeowners are being forced onto the California FAIR Plan, the state’s insurer of last resort.

• The FAIR Plan provides limited coverage—it only protects against fire, leaving homeowners to buy separate policies for other risks like liability, theft, and water damage.
  
  
• It doesn’t include Additional Living Expenses (ALE). Unlike traditional homeowners insurance, the FAIR Plan only provides Fair Rental Value (FRV) coverage, which compensates homeowners for lost rental income but does not cover their own temporary living expenses.
  
  
• Premiums on FAIR Plan policies are rising. With more homeowners relying on the FAIR Plan, costs are increasing, and the program is under pressure to remain solvent.

If the FAIR Plan runs out of money due to excessive wildfire losses, insurers that back it may be forced to absorb the costs, which could trigger further rate hikes or lead to even fewer options in the private market.

Stricter Underwriting and New Policy Requirements
With insurers facing rising risks, they’re implementing stricter guidelines before issuing or renewing policies.

• More home inspections required. Insurers now require proof of wildfire mitigation efforts, including defensible space, fire-resistant materials, and brush clearance.
  
  
• Higher deductibles and wildfire exclusions. Some policies now exclude coverage for wildfire losses or require significantly higher deductibles.
  
  
• Homes in high-risk areas are being denied outright. Many insurers will not write policies in areas with repeated wildfire claims or without adequate fire department access.

State Regulations Are Making the Crisis Worse
While wildfires are at the heart of the homeowners insurance crisis, California’s regulatory system is making it even harder for insurers to stay in the market.

• Proposition 103 restricts insurers from quickly adjusting rates. Unlike in most states, insurers in California must seek state approval before raising rates, a process that can take years even if claim costs are rising.
  
  
• Insurers are forced to set rates based on past losses, not future risks. Even if wildfires are expected to become more destructive, insurers can’t price policies accordingly until they’ve already lost money.
  ​
• Consumer advocacy groups can challenge rate increases. This leads to insurers pulling out of the market rather than waiting indefinitely for approval.

The result? Fewer insurers willing to write new policies, more homeowners stuck with the FAIR Plan, and rapidly rising premiums for everyone.

How to Fix California’s Homeowners Insurance Market
Just like with auto insurance, California needs major regulatory reforms to prevent further market collapse.
✅ Allow insurers to adjust rates based on future risk rather than waiting until they’ve already suffered losses.
✅ Expand mitigation incentives to encourage homeowners to make wildfire-resistant improvements.
✅ Strengthen the FAIR Plan’s financial stability to ensure coverage is available when needed.
✅ Encourage private insurers to return to the market by reducing regulatory delays and making wildfire risk more predictable.

Without these changes, homeowners will continue to see rising costs and fewer coverage options.
What Homeowners Can Do to Protect Themselves
Until meaningful reforms take place, homeowners should:
✔️ Ensure they have the right coverage. Standard policies may not cover wildfire damage if mitigation efforts aren’t met. Review policy limits and exclusions carefully.
✔️ Consider extended replacement cost coverage. With demand surge increasing rebuilding costs, homeowners should check if they have adequate coverage to rebuild their home.
✔️ Make fire-resistant home improvements. Some insurers offer discounts for defensible space, Class A roofing, and ember-resistant vents.
✔️ Explore personal umbrella policies. With liability claims increasing, an umbrella policy can provide extra protection beyond homeowners insurance limits.
✔️ Work with an experienced agent to navigate policy options and understand what’s available in a shrinking market.

Final Thoughts: What’s Next for California’s Homeowners Insurance Market?
The current crisis isn’t just about wildfire risk—it’s about how California regulates its insurance industry. Until meaningful reforms take place, homeowners will face higher costs, more non-renewals, and limited choices.

​At Schneiderman Insurance Agency, we do our best to make sure that our clients are well-protected with affordable and comprehensive policies. To learn more about how we can help you, please contact our agency at (818) 322-4744 or Click Here to request a free quote.

Disclaimer: The information presented in this blog is intended for informational purposes only and should not be considered as professional advice. It is crucial to consult with a qualified insurance agent or professional for personalized advice tailored to your specific circumstances. They can provide expert guidance and help you make informed decisions regarding your insurance needs.​